Think direct mail is impossible to measure? Think again. From QR codes to unique URLs, to incremental lift, here’s how ecommerce brands can track the performance of their postal campaigns.
In a world where every click, impression and conversion seems to come with a neatly packaged metric, direct mail can feel like the odd one out.
While direct mail may not offer the same immediate visibility as digital channels, there are plenty of ways to track its performance, understand customer behaviour and measure its contribution to revenue. In fact, when integrated with your existing marketing channels, direct mail can become a highly measurable part of your marketing mix.
At Paperplanes, we have our very own platform where, alongside creating your very own campaign, you will have access to a campaign analytics dashboard. This dashboard has live updates and can tell you everything you need to know from campaign cost to conversion rate to ROAS.
Stay in the know, every step of the way!
For many marketers, the challenge with postal marketing comes down to attribution. If a customer receives a postcard, visits your website three days later and makes a purchase, how do you know the postcard influenced their decision?
Traditional direct mail campaigns often relied on broad assumptions, such as comparing sales before and after a campaign. While this can offer some insight, it doesn’t necessarily tell you whether the mail itself drove the result.
The good news is that modern direct mail doesn’t have to operate in isolation. By combining physical mail with digital tracking, customer data and controlled testing, brands can build a much clearer picture of what their campaigns are actually delivering.

1. Unique URLs
One of the simplest ways to track direct mail performance is through unique URLs. Rather than directing customers to your homepage, you can create a dedicated landing page specifically for your postal campaign. For example, a skincare brand sending a postcard promoting a new product could direct customers to:
Yourbrand.co.uk/postcard
This allows you to track how many people visit the page as a result of receiving the mail. Unique URLs can also be used alongside UTM parameters, helping brands identify campaign traffic within tools such as Google Analytics.
This provides useful insight into:
- Landing page engagement
- Website visits generate by the campaign
- Conversion rates
- Revenue attributed to campaign traffic
2. QR Codes
QR codes are another effective way to bridge the gap between physical and digital marketing. Direct mail containing QR codes are 87% more likely to prompt a website visit.*
By adding a QR code to a postcard or letter, you give customers a quick and convenient way to engage with your brand. A scan can take them directly to a product page, exclusive offer, or a personalised landing page.
Most importantly, QR codes can be tracked.
By creating unique QR codes for different campaigns you can measure:
- The number of scans
- Engagement with the landing page and website
- Subsequent purchases
- Which creative campaign generates the strongest response
For example, a clothing brand could test two different postcard designs. By using separate QR codes, the brand can see which creative drives more engagement. At Paperplanes, we also do A/B testing where you can test two version of your campaigns to see which one performs better. The results of this will be available on our analytics dashboard, which is live 24/7, ensuring you always have your latest campaign results.
However, QR codes work best alongside other tracking methods because they don’t capture every conversion. For instance, some customers may receive your letter, visit your website independently and purchase without using the code. Others may share the code with someone else.
3. Incremental lift
Ultimately, the goal of any marketing campaign isn’t just to generate activity. It’s to generate additional value. Incremental lift measures the difference in performance between customers who receive a campaign and those who don’t.
For example, let’s say:
- The direct mail audience has a purchase rate of 8%
- The holdout audience has a purchase rate of 5%
The incremental lift is 3%.
This means the campaign generated a 60% relative increase in purchase rate compared with the holdout group.
4. Our Proof
Paperplanes recently worked with Modern Milkman who needed support in reengaging customers who had lost interest from email marketing.
We set up a 3 trigger based mail campaign targeting distinct audience segments. Each campaign used a personalised postcard with branding on both sides and unique discount codes. Customer data was pulled from The Modern Milkman’s API, with a frequency cap to ensure customers received no more than one mailing every 30 days.
This case study proves that direct mail is beneficial and measurable. Across 7,152 mailings, the mailed cohort consistently outperformed the control group, with the Abandoned Basket campaign achieving a 78.8% conversion rate uplift against the control group. There was also an 11% customer reactivation through personalised automated direct mail.
And of course, Modern Milkman were able to track this data throughout the campaign using our platform.
Click here to read more: https://paperplanes.co.uk/modern-milkman/
Book your demo today and make your direct mail measurable with Paperplanes.
*Source: JICMAIL Q2 2026 Results: Political parties and supermarkets provide a boost to mail engagement and effectiveness. [jicmail.org.uk]
